Wilson Plot and E Statistics
https://xraytools.com/wilson
The evidence systematic absences cannot give. A centre of inversion forces every phase to 0 or 180°, which leaves a mark on the distribution of the intensities rather than on which of them are missing — so it is measurable exactly where the determination runs out. The same shell averages give the Wilson plot, whose slope against (sin θ/λ)² is −2B, with B the overall displacement parameter.
- Before this
- The evidence here is the distribution of intensities rather than any one of them, so |F|² and what makes it large or small is assumed — see the structure factor.
- You supply
- One of the named structures. A full set of reflections is computed from its atoms, so nothing has to be measured — and an overall B can be added to see the plot tilt.
- Reading it
- Wilson's derivation assumes many atoms of comparable scattering power sitting at random. A structure whose atoms are all on special positions has every atom placed by the symmetry — fixed outright, or confined to a line or a plane — so the statistic means nothing there, and the page refuses a verdict rather than giving the wrong one.
Worked examples: albite, 52 atoms in the cell — centrosymmetric · quartz, no centre of inversion · cristobalite — the same, from different symmetry · albite with an overall B of 3 Ų · rutile — where the test does not apply · berlinite — where the test is confidently wrong · albite scaled by 1000 — the intercept gives it back · zirconia — where N(z) answers and the statistic cannot
Earlier on the path: The Patterson Function Next on the path: Direct Methods and the Sign Relation On From intensities to a structure, step 4 of 7
Notation here: s · F, |F| · I · E · U, B · K — what each one means here
Terms here: reflection · centring · general position · zone
See also: Intensity Corrections · Space Group from Absences · Structure Factor Calculator
What each input changes
- Overall B
- An overall displacement parameter added to the computed data. It tilts the plot: the slope against (sin θ/λ)² is −2B, which is what makes the plot readable backwards.
Teaching with this page
- Objective
- After this page a learner can read the overall displacement parameter and the scale off a Wilson plot, and say whether the intensity statistics point to a centre of inversion.
- Start from
- this worked example
- Ask first
- Two crystals of one compound give Wilson plots, and one slope is steeper. Are that crystal’s atoms vibrating more?
- Watch for
- “Yes — the slope measures thermal motion”
- Then
- Direct Methods and the Sign Relation
Check yourself: Two crystals of one compound give Wilson plots, and one slope is steeper. Are that crystal’s atoms vibrating more?
Not necessarily — B is any spread of the atoms about their sites Yes — the slope measures thermal motion
The slope is −2B, and B = 8π²〈u²〉 is the mean-square displacement of the atoms from their average sites, whatever moves them there. Vibration is one cause. Static disorder, atoms sitting slightly differently from one cell to the next, is another, and one data set cannot tell the two apart (Trueblood et al. 1996, cited on the displacement parameters page); measuring at more than one temperature is how the thermal part is separated.
Input
Systematic absences see the centring, the glide planes and the screw axes, and they cannot see a centre of inversion: two groups built from the same centring, glides and screws — C2/c and Cc, Pnma and Pn21a — extinguish exactly the same reflections whether or not one of them has that centre. That is why the determination hands back a family of groups, and this statistic is the independent evidence that separates them.
Has it got a centre of inversion?
Systematic absences cannot answer that, which is why the determination hands back a family of space groups rather than one. The intensities can: a centre of inversion forces every phase to 0 or 180°, and that leaves a mark on the distribution of the intensities which no amount of careful indexing would show.
Choose a structure and this computes a full set of reflections from its atoms, fits the Wilson plot to get the overall displacement parameter B back out, and measures 〈||E|2 − 1|〉.
Some of the named structures can be judged this way and some cannot — the page says which, and why, rather than answering anyway.
Try it
albite, 52 atoms in the cell — centrosymmetric · quartz, no centre of inversion · cristobalite — the same, from different symmetry · albite with an overall B of 3 Ų · rutile — where the test does not apply · berlinite — where the test is confidently wrong · albite scaled by 1000 — the intercept gives it back · zirconia — where N(z) answers and the statistic cannot
Where this comes from
- The probability distribution of X-ray intensities
A. J. C. Wilson, Acta Cryst. 1949, 2, 318–321 · doi:10.1107/S0365110X49000813
The intensity statistics: the two distributions the measured intensities are compared with, centred and not. - Determination of absolute from relative X-ray intensity data
A. J. C. Wilson, Nature 1942, 150, 152 · doi:10.1038/150152a0
The plot and the scaling: the straight line whose intercept puts the data on an absolute scale and whose slope, −2B, gives the overall B.